PDA

View Full Version : Nasty Stuff


ICE420
December 17th, 2007, 01:04 AM
The shocking face of rugby

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00405/Kieran_Roche_405466a.jpg

PERRY FRESHWATER could face a hefty ban for putting London Irish forward Kieran Roche in hospital.

Irish are demanding action after Roche was elbowed in the face in their 23-6 Heineken Cup defeat at Perpignan.

London director Brian Smith was enraged by the incident. He blasted: “These sort of things should not be happening on a rugby pitch.”

But Mike Catt has defended England team-mate Freshwater from accusations of blinding an opponent.

Flanker Roche, 28, suffered a fractured eye-socket and was temporarily blinded in his left eye.

But World Cup hero Catt, who left the Stade Aime Giral field with a back injury shortly after club-mate Roche, insisted: “I know Perry and he’s not a malicious player.” Match officials failed to act because they could not identify the culprit.

But the citing commissioner, armed with video evidence, is certain to take action and has until 5.30pm today to act. That could lead to England World Cup loosehead prop Freshwater, 34, missing most or all of the Six Nations Championship.

But Smith had no sympathy and added: “Roche was blind in his left eye on Saturday night.

“When Freshwater took Roche out, it cost us a crucial lineout forward. It was a huge loss for us.

“We had issues last week at home against Perpignan when one of our players had his head stamped on.

“We’ve written to organisers European Rugby Cup but so far have had no response.”

By the time Roche had a second hospital scan yesterday back in London, his vision was restored but blurred.

Catt added: “We certainly won’t leave Perpignan with our confidence knocked.

“At half-time the game was anybody’s and after two crucial moments — the yellow card to Delon Armitage and the loss of Roche — they finally got the better of us.”

The two sides were locked together at 6-6 well into the second half but Armitage’s yellow card for a high tackle was the turning point.

Perpignan scored through Christophe Manas and Nathan Hines but still trail the Exiles by one point in Pool 1.


http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sport/rugby_union/article589111.ece

boo_cocky
December 17th, 2007, 01:08 AM
Can't these guys wear a Lacrosse type helmet or something? They're small, light, but offer protection.

I mean, it's not quite American football, but rugby is definitely a pretty rough sport...I'm shocked this type of thing, and worse, doesn't happen more frequently.

ICE420
December 17th, 2007, 01:20 AM
Can't these guys wear a Lacrosse type helmet or something? They're small, light, but offer protection.

I mean, it's not quite American football, but rugby is definitely a pretty rough sport...I'm shocked this type of thing, and worse, doesn't happen more frequently.

I´m not a huge rugby fan to be honest, but I think they have some type of protection for the head and ears, but I don´t ever recall seeing any face guard? I could be wrong, Cymru would be the man to answer that.

Afronaught
December 17th, 2007, 01:28 AM
Unsporstman like behavior....

There are scrum caps to protect your ears from being ripped off.. and rules do not allow for a high tackle around the neck...

An Elbow to the face is just pure vindictivness.

Snuff.
December 17th, 2007, 01:34 AM
Rugby`s a pretty fast game - much faster generally speaking and in relation to the consistency of in-time play,# than American football. In that sense, I`d imagine that Rugby would be much more difficult to play with anything inflicting head movement or general field of view than AF.

That, and AF players take far harder knocks far more frequently than those playing rugby.

:2twocents:

boo_cocky
December 17th, 2007, 01:39 AM
Rugby`s a pretty fast game - much faster generally speaking and in relation to the consistency of in-time play,# than American football. In that sense, I`d imagine that Rugby would be much more difficult to play with anything inflicting head movement or general field of view than AF.

That, and AF players take far harder knocks far more frequently than those playing rugby.

:2twocents:

I was thinking of the fast paced aspect of it too...I'm not very familiar with rugby, but lacrosse is also fast paced and doesn't seem to affect playability...

Also, the lacrosse ball is much smaller and certainly harder to see...but, they have a face guarded helmet...?

logandk
December 17th, 2007, 02:41 AM
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a141/logandk/rugby_headgear_ventilator.jpg

Canterbury Rugby Honeycomb headgear ...

No face guard.

brownbearclan
December 17th, 2007, 06:11 PM
Can't these guys wear a Lacrosse type helmet or something? They're small, light, but offer protection.

I mean, it's not quite American football, but rugby is definitely a pretty rough sport...I'm shocked this type of thing, and worse, doesn't happen more frequently.

I've actually wondered the same thing myself. I don't care if people thought I was a pussy, I'd wear a helmet while playing rugby lol.